Exculpation and Indemnification in a Syndication Operating Agreement: What Investors Should Check
On this page
Exculpation and indemnification clauses decide who pays when something goes wrong in a syndication. An exculpation clause says the sponsor (usually the manager of the deal's LLC) is not liable to the company or the investors for its decisions, except in listed cases. An indemnification clause says the company pays the sponsor's losses and legal costs from claims that arise from its role, again except in listed cases. Both clauses are standard. The questions for an investor are what the exceptions (carve-outs) are, whether the agreement also waives the sponsor's fiduciary duties, and where the indemnity money comes from.
This guide shows what the clauses say, what a reasonable version looks like, and what to ask. For the whole document, read the syndication operating agreement.
What does an exculpation clause do?
It sets the standard of conduct below which the sponsor is liable. A typical clause says the manager is not liable to the company or its members for any act or omission in good faith, except in listed cases. Without such a clause, a sponsor could in principle be sued for ordinary business mistakes, such as buying in a market that turned, picking a contractor who ran over budget or choosing a floating-rate loan before rates rose. Exculpation means investors accept that business judgment calls can go wrong without the sponsor paying for them personally.
What it should not do is protect the sponsor from serious misconduct. The usual carve-outs:
| Carve-out | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Fraud | Lying to investors or the company |
| Willful misconduct | Deliberately doing what the sponsor knows is wrong |
| Gross negligence | Extreme carelessness, well beyond an ordinary mistake |
| Knowing violation of law | Breaking a law on purpose |
| Material breach of the agreement | Not doing what the operating agreement requires |
| Bad faith or self-dealing | Acting for the sponsor's own benefit against the company |
A clause that exculpates for "anything other than fraud" is much narrower protection for investors than one with the full list.
What does an indemnification clause do?
It makes the company cover the sponsor's losses, judgments, settlements and legal fees from claims that arise from managing the deal. Under Delaware's LLC Act, section 18-108, an LLC may indemnify any member, manager or other person, subject to whatever standards its agreement sets. Most states give LLCs a similar power.
Indemnity has a real cost to investors: money the company pays to defend or reimburse the sponsor is money that is not distributed. Check three points:
- Same carve-outs as exculpation. No indemnity for fraud, willful misconduct, gross negligence, bad faith, an improper personal benefit or a breach of the duty of loyalty.
- Company assets only. Indemnity is paid from the company's assets, never by investors personally, and never through a capital call. See what is a capital call.
- Advancement. Some agreements let the company advance legal fees before a case ends. A fair clause requires the sponsor to repay them if it turns out not to be entitled.
Can an operating agreement waive fiduciary duties?
It depends on the state. Delaware's LLC Act lets an agreement expand, restrict or eliminate fiduciary duties, but not the implied contractual covenant of good faith and fair dealing. Many other states follow a uniform LLC act that lets the agreement adjust duties only within limits. An agreement that eliminates duties entirely and exculpates for everything except fraud leaves investors with little recourse besides the contract itself.
Read the duties section next to the exculpation clause. If the agreement says the manager owes no duties "except as expressly set forth here", look at what is expressly set forth.
What these clauses do not cover
- Securities laws. An operating agreement cannot waive investors' rights under the federal securities laws. A sponsor who makes a materially false or misleading statement to sell interests can face liability under Rule 10b-5 regardless of the agreement. See Rule 10b-5 and sponsor statements.
- Removal. Exculpation limits money claims; it does not stop investors from using the agreement's removal for cause provisions.
- Insurance. Sponsors often carry directors and officers or errors and omissions coverage, which can pay claims before the company's money does. See syndication insurance for sponsors.
What DoorRaise's standard agreement says
In DoorRaise's standard operating agreement, the Manager is not liable for any act or omission in good faith, except fraud, willful misconduct, gross negligence, a knowing violation of law or a material breach of the agreement. The company indemnifies the Manager for claims arising from its role, except in those same cases, and never for bad faith, an improper personal benefit or a breach of the duty of loyalty. Indemnity is paid only from company assets, never by members personally. Each deal's offering documents hold the terms that apply to it, so read them before you sign.
Questions to ask the sponsor
- What are the exact carve-outs from exculpation and indemnification?
- Does the agreement waive or narrow fiduciary duties, and under which state's law?
- Is indemnity limited to company assets? Can it trigger a capital call?
- Are legal fees advanced, and must they be repaid if the sponsor loses?
- What insurance does the sponsor carry, and does the company pay for it?
See more in questions to ask a sponsor before investing.
How DoorRaise fits in
DoorRaise helps sponsors raise equity for apartment buildings with 5+ units from their friends and followers under Rule 506(b) or 506(c), with standard offering documents that every investor can read before signing. Escrow is at Enterprise Bank & Trust, an FDIC-insured bank, and investors fund by wire only. See pricing. DoorRaise is not a law firm, broker-dealer, investment adviser, funding portal or bank, and it represents neither the sponsor nor the investors.
Raise your apartment deal from the people who already follow you.
DoorRaise is built for apartment buildings with 5 or more units: one link for the deal, escrow until closing and a standard fee card.
Ready to raise? Create your free sponsor page or see pricing.
FAQ
Is an exculpation clause a red flag?
No. Nearly every syndication has one. A clause with few carve-outs, combined with a full waiver of fiduciary duties, deserves a closer look.
Does indemnification mean investors pay the sponsor's legal bills?
The company pays, so indirectly yes, out of money that would otherwise go to investors. A fair clause excludes misconduct and is paid only from company assets.
Can I negotiate these clauses?
Individual investors rarely can in a single deal, since every investor signs the same agreement. Some ask for side letters on other terms; see side letters.
What is gross negligence?
Courts describe it as extreme carelessness or reckless indifference, well beyond an ordinary mistake. The exact standard depends on the state's law.
Next step: see what other rights you hold in investor rights in a syndication.
Sources
- Delaware Code, Title 6, Chapter 18 (Limited Liability Company Act)
- Delaware Code, Title 6, Chapter 18, Subchapter XI (section 18-1101)
- 17 CFR 240.10b-5, employment of manipulative and deceptive devices
This article is general information, not legal or investment advice. The law differs by state. Talk to your own attorney before you invest. DoorRaise is not a law firm, broker-dealer, investment adviser or funding portal.